GST Advantages and Disadvantages: Is It Truly Beneficial?
Introduction: The Goods and Services Tax (GST), a pivotal reform in the nation, merges various indirect taxes like excise, VAT, and service tax governing the sale of goods and services domestically. Let's delve into its pros and cons:
Advantages of GST1. Elimination of Cascading Tax Effect
GST simplifies indirect taxation by removing the 'Tax on Tax' phenomenon prevalent earlier.
Example:
Before GST: A consultant bills Rs. 50,000 with a 15% service tax (Rs. 7,500). Buying office supplies for Rs. 20,000 incurs a VAT of 5% (Rs. 1,000), without deduction, leading to a total tax of Rs. 8,500.
Under GST: 18% GST on Rs. 50,000 is Rs. 9,000; deducting Rs. 1,000 GST on supplies results in Rs. 8,000 net GST.
2. Higher Registration Threshold
Under prior VAT laws, businesses exceeding a Rs. 5 lakh turnover in most states had VAT obligations. GST raises this threshold to Rs. 20 lakh, sparing numerous small enterprises.
3. Composition Scheme for Small Businesses: GST offers a Composition scheme for turnovers between Rs. 20 to 75 lakhs, easing tax burdens.
4. Simplified Online Procedure
The GST process is entirely online, facilitating a seamless experience, especially advantageous for startups.
Clear GST aids in timely filing of accurate returns.
5. Reduced Compliance Burden
Previously distinct VAT and service tax returns are unified under GST, simplifying compliance.
6. E-Commerce Regulation
Unified GST rules for e-commerce operations negate previous state-wise VAT discrepancies.
7. Efficient Logistics
GST mitigates state-wise warehousing needs lingering from prior tax structures, enhancing logistics.
8. Regulating Unorganized Sectors
GST introduces accountability in sectors like construction via regulated, online payment procedures.
Disadvantages of GST
1. Software Costs
Businesses must invest in GST-compliance software and train staff accordingly.
ClearGST delivers innovative solutions for seamless adherence.
2. Penalties for Non-compliance
Violating GST norms attracts penalties, mandating businesses to issue compliant invoices accurately.
3. Increased Operational Costs
The shift in tax filing procedures often necessitates hiring GST specialists, raising costs for small businesses.
ClearGST offers cost-effective compliance tools.
4. Transitioning Challenges
Mid-year GST implementation stirred complexity during the shift from old tax regimes.
5. Online Taxation Adaptation
Smaller entities grappled with moving to digital invoicing and payment systems.
ClearGST's platform streamlines e-filing.
6. Tax Burden on SMEs
GST impacts smaller manufacturers with turnovers over Rs. 20 lakhs unless they adopt the lower-rate Composition scheme. However, this disqualifies input tax credit claims.
In conclusion, while change can pose challenges, the government continually refines GST for smoother execution. Global models inform these reforms, and advancements in AI and ML aid in reducing revenue leakages, promising benefits of a unified tax system.